Risk, Uncertainty and Profit
Knight is best known for Knightian uncertainty. Frequently described as a context for decision-making in which not even the probability distributions of the outcomes of future actions are known, uncertainty is also sometimes distinguished from risk by its uninsurability (Knight 1999b: 345).
If the outcomes of future actions can be quantified in any way, market participants can find ways to insure themselves against future risks, converting them into known costs. If the outcomes cannot be measured in some way, insurance markets will not emerge, and entrepreneurs will have to bear negative outcomes themselves. Human action in the context of Knightian uncertainty, then, is based on subjective estimates of the future outcomes of potential actions. Knightian uncertainty is often called an epistemological problem because it identifies the limit of human knowledge. However, Knight’s discussion of uncertainty as the grounds forentrepreneurial action, and hence the reason for the existence of economic profit, also makes it an interpersonal, even moral, problem. The “true uncertainty,” he says, is our uncertainty about the capacity of others to “meet uncertainty” (Knight 1921: 309). The entrepreneur accepts that challenge, making judgements about the capabilities of those hired, even though they may cost the entrepreneur dearly.
Because Knight identified economic decision-making in the context of uncertainty as the fundamental departure of actual economic life from perfect competition theory, Knightian uncertainty is generally considered a foundational contribution to the theory of entrepreneurship and is indirectly linked to the development of non-neoclassical theories of the firm. Douglass North has made the concept integral to his historical work on the process of economic change (North 2005), and it has come to be used in financial economics as a counter to the use of Bayesian subjective probabilities in market forecasting.
More on the topic Risk, Uncertainty and Profit:
- George Lennox Sharman Shackle (1903-1992)
- Concluding remarks
- Old and new political arithmetic and “social mathematic”
- Before the Enlightenment
- Mr. Keynes and the "classics"5 - and Modern Keynesians
- John Richard Hicks (1904-1989)
- Public economics (2): monopoly, price differentiation and taxation
- Economic thought during World War II and the “Trente Glorieuses”
- Kenneth Joseph Arrow (b. 1921)
- INDEX